Friday 9 December 2022

2022 Greatest Songs: Part 4 (999-750)

Here are more. I've been listening to the songs topping the Best of lists for 2022, to see if I frantically need to change anything ... not quite ...

999        Meet On The Ledge - Fairport Convention

998        Oliver's Army - Elvis Costello

997        The Tide Is High - The Paragons/Blondie

996        Rainbow - Kacey Musgraves

995        The Weekend - SZA

994        Feel Good Inc. - Gorillaz

993        Drops of Jupiter - Train

992        Take a Bow - Madonna

991        The Drowners - Suede

990        Never Too Much - Luther Vandross

989        U Sexy Thing - Hot Chocolate

988        Itchycoo Park - Small Faces

987        Solitaire - Neil Sedaka

986        Stormy Weather - Lena Horne

985        Summer in the City - Lovin' Spoonful

984        Get Up Offa That Thing - James Brown

983        Everything I Own - Bread/Ken Holt

982        I Try - Macy Gray

981        Enjoy the Silence - Depeche Mode

980        Casimir Pulaski Day - Sufjan Stevens

979        Oblivion – Grimes

I must have taken my eye off the ball a little in the early 2010s. Definitely, there was more highly acclaimed music from that point that I just couldn’t quite get. It’s been far from terminal. There’s still loads of stuff I love and I listen to more new music than ever, but there is unquestionably more material on the top of critics' lists that makes me feel like an embattled grandad than there used to be.

Embodying this new confusion are Grimes and Frank Ocean. I understand what’s fun, intriguing, talented about them, but I just have not loved any of either’s songs, despite a fairly considerable effort. I just think my ears are wrong for it. Other people are hearing something magical, new and powerful that I’m missing, something  that has moved the dial and rewritten the rulebook I stolidly adhere to. Or maybe I’m right and it’s emperor’s new clothes mediocrity, after all. We’ll see.

Anyway, safe to say, Grimes and Frank Ocean superfans, this is a bad list I’m making. 

978        Roar - Katy Perry

977        Vossi Bop - Stormzy

976        Tramp the Dirt Down - Elvis Costello

975        Come Out 2Nite - Kenickie

974        Here's Where the Story Ends - The Sundays

973        So What - Pink

People, including me, often talk about a song being perfect, which, of course, implies a standard. Songs can’t really be perfect, thankfully, but we know what the word means when applied to a song, and there’s not many songs described as “perfect” that aren’t thrilling songs. But the quest for perfection can’t be everything. There are clearly songwriters – Mann/Weill, King/Goffin, Holland/Dozier/Holland, Andersson/Ulvaeus, Diane Warren, Max Martin etc, who, at times, were just so on top of their craft, so tapped into the business of creating hit songs, that they could barely go wrong, and there’s something not just satisfying but also a little depressing about that. Writing a hit shouldn’t be so easy … for anyone. There needs to be more than perfection – there needs to be stretching the limits, to be lucky mistakes, to be moments of candour and shock, to be words and sounds that don’t seem like they belong in a pop song but somehow do. Perfection changes.

Anyway, I love So What, and it doesn't sound formulaic, and, like very many 21st century hits, it's co-written by Max Martin.

972        Let's Go Fly a Kite - Mary Poppins

971        The Twist - Chubby Checker

970        Fever - Peggy Lee

969        Just My Imagination (Running Away With Me) - The Temptations

968        Up the Junction - Squeeze

967        The Breaks - Kurtis Blow

966        Some Girls - Rachel Stevens

965        The Dark Is Rising - Mercury Rev

964        Take Me Out - Franz Ferdinand

963        Old Town Road - Lil Nas X

962        Cuff It - Beyonce

961        The Final Countdown - Europe

960        Dreams - The Cranberries

959        Thou Shalt Always Kill - Dan Le Sac vs Scroobious Pip

958        I Write the Songs - Barry Manilow

957        Can You Feel It - The Jacksons

956        Close to You - The Carpenters

955        Vincent - Don McLean

954        Waiting in Vain - Bob Marley

953        Summertime Blues - Eddie Cochran

952        Band of Gold - Freda Payne

951        Dreams - Fleetwood Mac

I used to imagine the methodology for all the Greatest Songs and Greatest Albums lists in music magazines was simply one person carefully deciding how best to irritate and provoke David McGaughey, but I think, although sometimes some of the smaller lists probably are pretty casually judged by one or two experts (or so-called bloody experts, eh?), that the big lists, like Rolling Stone and Pitchfork, really do employ a pretty assiduous methodology, a huge sample size of journalists and musicians across the board.

Yet, nevertheless, that allows for a certain groupthink, of people concertedly all trying to do the right thing, pick the winners, right previous wrongs. Or sometimes there’s a trigger I’ve missed. 

I don’t really know why Dreams by Fleetwood Mac was suddenly in Rolling Stone’s Top 10 songs of All Time last year, why suddenly a critical mass was voting for it, when for a long time it had only been at the lower reaches of such lists, if there at all. But then I see, on the list of most streamed songs for each year, that Dreams is the most streamed of 1976, and I realise I’ve missed something more organic and true than I’d thought.

950        Street Fighting Man - Rolling Stones

949        All Along the Watchtower - Jimi Hendrix

I know it’s boring that I mention Dylan more than anyone else, but, of course, you know that if I was being honest about what I actually think are the greatest songs, there’d be about 150 Dylan songs. What’s the 150th Greatest Dylan song … I don’t know … maybe Senor (Tales of Yankee Power) – and sure, I think that’s greater than whatever I have at the bottom.

Anyway, as penance, on noticing I didn't have All Along the Watchtower in the list, which I'm sure i meant to have, i have taken out 'Don't Think Twice It's Alright' and replaced it with the Hendrix 'All Along the Watchtower', and the world continues to turn.

948        Brown Eyed Girl - Van Morrison

947        Return Of The Grievous Angel - Gram Parsons

946        Desperado - The Eagles

945        St Elmo's Fire - John Parr

944        The Mother We Share - Chvrches

943        Scenes from an Italian Restaurant - Billy Joel

942        Don't Dream It's Over - Crowded House

941        Something Coming - West Side Story

940        Route 66 - Nat King Cole

939        Signed, Sealed, Delivered - Stevie Wonder

938        Sometimes - Erasure

937        Are You That Somebody - Aaliyah

936        Sinnerman - Nina Simone

935        I Got a Feeling - Black Eyed Peas

934        Piano Man - Billy Joel

933        Just One of the Guys - Jenny Lewis

932        Heart Like a Wheel - The McGarrigles

931        Leave the Door Open - SilkSonic

930        I Predict a Riot - Kaiser Chiefs

929        Celebrity Skin - Hole

928        Sour Times - Portishead

927        True - Spandau Ballet

926        Baker Street - Gerry Rafferty

925        Everlasting Love - Love Affair

924        My Wandering Days are Over - Belle and Sebastian

923        Save the Last Dance for Me - The Drifters

922        Hellhound on My Trail - Robert Johnson

921        Do What You Gotta Do - The Four Tops

920        School Days - Loudon Wainwright

919        Blood on the Leaves - Kanye West

918        Someone Like You - Adele

917        Long Time Coming - Delays

916        Back For Good - Take That

915        This is How We Do It - Montell Jordan

914        Heart-Shaped Box - Nirvana

913        The Sick Bed of Cuchulainn - The Pogues

912        Ain't Nobody - Chaka Khan

911        Que Sera, Sera (Whatever Will Be, Will Be) - Doris Day

910        One for My Baby (and One for the Road) - Frank Sinatra

909        I've Been Loving You Too Long (To Stop Now) - Otis Redding

908        Whiter Shade of Pale - Procul Harum

907        Reelin' In The Years - Steely Dan

906        Sweet Dreams (Are Made Of This) - Eurythmics

905        Bizarre Love Triangle - New Order

904        Get Lucky - Daft Punk

Check out Daft Punk's new single "Get Lucky" if you get the chance. Sound of the summer.

903        You Never Can Tell - Chuck Berry

902        Lloyd, I'm Ready to be Heartbroken - Camera Obscura

901        Come on Eileen - Dexys Midnight Runners

900        PYT - Michael Jackson

899        A Song for You - Leon Russell

898        Walk on the Wild Side - Lou Reed

897        The Dark End of the Street - James Carr

896        Jubilee Street - Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds

895        Emmylou - First Aid Kit

894        I Don't Feel like Dancing - Scissor Sisters

893        Nutmeg - Ghostface Killah

892        Unbelievable - EMF

891        Justified and Ancient - The KLF ft Tammy Wynette

890        Tainted Love - Soft Cell

889        Sweet Love - Anita Baker

888        Happy Hour - The Housemartins

887        Drive - Cars

886        Mysteries - Beth Gibbons

885        One Armed Scissor - At the Drive-In

884        LES Artistes - Santigold

883        Ignore Tenderness - Julia Jacklin

882        Sign of the Times - Harry Styles

881        Never Ever - All Saints

880        Sit Down – James

But anyway, I’m more conscious than last time, than ever,  that a pop song’s greatness is not primarily about its structure and its intricacies - although they do matter, and it is little details, little structural hints, which guide us towards the music we love - but it is meaning and impact above all that makes a pop song great. Meaning something, anything. Meaning quite a lot to a great many people or a huge amount to a fairly small amount of people. How much Sit Down by James means to some people, or how much Alright by Kendrick Lamar means to others.

879        We'll Meet Again - Vera Lynn

878        Femme Fatale - The Velvet Underground

877        I Will Always Love You - Dolly Parton

876        Jealous Guy - John Lennon

875        River - Joni Mitchell

874        Where Is My Mind? - The Pixies

873        Somewhere Only We Know – Keane

I was thinking, again, about songs that I thought were great when I first heard them … I thought of, wait for it, 212 by Azealia Banks and Somewhere Only We Know by Keane, which I’d guess is the first time those two songs have ever been in the same sentence. You know, 212 remains mind-blowingly, hilariously, unmatchably fun and good, and of course not possible to play on the radio or in front of anyone you don’t implicitly trust for more than a few seconds. I’d read it was really great, and I listened to it, and it could probably have changed everything I’d ever felt about music if there’d been more like it.

Which is not true of Somewhere Only We Know, which is very much in my natural range, but, you know, deserves more credit than it gets. I remember listening to it for the first time, when I listened to a lot of solid indie radio, and there was lots, roughly, of that kind of stuff around, and with Somewhere Only We Know, as I listened, thinking, this is pretty clear and strong, I wonder if it has a chorus, they usually don’t make it to the chorus, and, hey presto, this one really had a chorus.

Keane were never going to be given a chance, the way they sounded, the way they looked, to be anything but despised and extremely successful.

Bit unfair, really. I read an interview with Tom Chaplin recently and I quite warmed to him, he was very clear-minded – in particularly he was pretty gently admonitory towards Coldplay – the extent to which they have relentlessly committed to bigness, to pop/rockstardom, and never really taken a risk. Of four massive bore-rock bands of that time … Travis, Coldplay, Keane, Snow Patrol, say what you like, the other three apart from Coldplay did some weird songs with proper lyrics, changed styles, gave themselves the opportunity to fail, and did fail, and in admirable ways, at times. I’m not a huge fan of Keane, but they did a few other pretty good, odd, songs later on, and this song just towers in its towering way, and I’m just fine with that.

872        Wrecking Ball - Miley Cyrus

871        Idioteque - Radiohead

870        Single Ladies - Beyonce

869        Kashmir - Led Zeppelin

868        Teenage Kicks - The Undertones

867        Pretend We're Dead - L7

866        Smile - Nat King Cole

865        Wake Up - Arcade Fire

864        Ticket To Ride - Beatles

863        You Got the Love - Candi Staton

862        Language Of Violence - Disposable Heroes Of Hiphoprisy

861        Hold On - Alabama Shakes

860        Mid Air - Paul Buchanan

I remember seeing Paul Buchanan, who was the leader of the Blue Nile, on Jools Holland, playing this song then talking about this song being as close as he'd got to ... I can't remember his exact words ... but something like ... the pure song ... or the bones of the song. Something like that. This song is so precise, small and beautiful.

859        Walk Away Renee - The Left Banke/Four Tops

858        The Wild Ones - Suede

857        Tell It Like It Is - Aaron Neville

856        Relax - Frankie Goes To Hollywood

855        I Put A Spell On You - Screaming Jay Hawkins

854        The Revolution Will Not Be Televised - Gil Scott-Heron

853        Under the Boardwalk - The Drifters

852        Get Off My Cloud - The Rolling Stones

851        Stand! - Sly and the Family Stone

850        Fistful Of Love - Antony and the Johnsons

849        Iris - Goo Good Dolls

If there one thing I love more than lists, it's lists- this one's about most streamed songs of every year https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-63490691 This is very handy, and fairly interesting. A lot of it is was you’d expect. It’s interesting the extent to which boy balladeers lead the way in recent years, going back to Wonderwall, but then hardly at all before that, where it’s anthems and party songs all the way.

I find some of the sappy boy songs hard going, but I wouldn’t be too scathing about your James Arthurs and your Passengers. The songs are put together perfectly well, and they’re not that far from what I like, or what I used to like. It’s, of course, galling that the two songs that have stood the test of time from my halcyon post-millennial days are Dancing in the Moonlight and How You Remind Me, very special versions of hell. But, anyway, one has to accept that most of these tracks need to be called great pop songs, one way or another.

848        Freedom - Beyonce ft Kendrick Lamar

847        Sons and Daughters - The Decemberists

846        Do You Realize?? - The Flaming Lips

845        End Of The Road - Boyz II Men

844        I Feel Fine - The Beatles

843        Runaway - Del Shannon

842        Simple Twist Of Fate - Bob Dylan

841        White Man in Hammersmith Palais - The Clash

840        If There's Any Justice - Lemar

839        Mr Bojangles - Nina Simone

838        Goldfinger - Shirley Bassey

837        I Believe When I Fall in Love with You It Will be Forever - Stevie Wonder

836        Tomorrow (From "Annie")

835        Tumbling Dice - The Rolling Stones

834        Sprawl 2 - Arcade Fire

833        Hotline Bling - Drake

832        Patience - Take That

831        White Winter Hymnal - Fleet Foxes

830        Leave Right Now - Will Young

829        Kids - MGMT

828        Motorcycle Emptiness - Manic Street Preachers

827        Connection - Elastica

826        Tempted - Squeeze

825        Saturday Night at the Movies - The Drifters

824        And Your Bird Can Sing - The Beatles

823        Rescue Me - Fontella Bass

822        Tupelo Honey - Van Morrison

821        Trash - New York Dolls

820        The Boys of Summer - Don Henley

819        Jump Around - House of Pain

818        Chicago - Sufjan Stevens

817        Can't Fight the Feeling - Justin Timberlake

816        Bad Religion - Frank Ocean

815        On and On - The Longpigs

814        Gloria - Patti Smith/Van Morrison

813        Can You Get to That – Funkadelic

I’ve come to the viewpoint – and any Bob Dylan fan/apologist would say this – that it doesn’t matter how you come to the song, it’s only the song that people hear that counts. If you steal someone’s words and melody, but do it well enough, get away with it, it’s yours. If you do a cover which makes people forget the original, good on you. If your trick for making great pop songs is simple, cynical and banal, but they still sound like great pop songs, so be it. That doesn’t mean this kind of stuff doesn’t matter to me as a listener, but if it doesn’t matter, then it doesn’t matter. I hope that makes sense.

I mean, sure, it so happens that I never really liked ‘Start!’ as Jam songs go, because I knew it was a rip-off of Taxman, but, until today I didn’t know that Rill Rill, by Sleigh Bells – which I casually have loved for a decade or so - wasn’t an original sound but sampled from this Funkadelic track. That doesn’t detract from how much I loved the song until now – it might in the future, I’ll hear a different song, but that’s a different matter. I don’t really believe in plagiarism in popular song anyway, only 12 notes and all that. Pay people if you directly use their actual recorded song, otherwise, all bets are off, I reckon. There we go, hope that solves it.

812        After the Love Has Gone - Earth, Wind and Fire

811        Believe - Cher

810        Gigantic - The Pixies

809        Find the River - REM

808        Angela Surf City - The Walkmen

807        Right Here - SWV

806        I'm Too Sexy - Right Side Fred

805        Under Pressure - Queen and David Bowie

804        Baby I Love You - The Ronettes

803        Nightshift - The Commodores

802        Imagine - John Lennon

801        Cum On Feel The Noise - Slade

800        When I Fall In Love - Nat King Cole

799        Candle in the Wind - Elton John

798        Fire and Rain - James Taylor

797        Blackstar- David Bowie

796        Martha - Tom Waits

795        Live and Let Die - Wings

794        Stop - Erasure

793        All Apologies - Nirvana

792        Pink Rabbits - The National

791        Never Loved A Man He Way That I Loved You - Aretha Franklin

790        Prince Charming - Adam and the Ants

789        Fake Plastic Trees - Radiohead

788        I Can't Stop Loving You - Ray Charles

787        Sweet Talkin' Woman - ELO

786        Two Princes - Spin Doctors

785        Danny Nedelko - Idles

784        Song to the Siren - This Mortal Coil/Tim Buckley

783        Wake Me Up Before you Go-Go - Wham!

782        Buddy Holly - Weezer

781        Heaven - The Walkmen

780        Archie. Marry Me - Alvvays

779        The Life You Chose - Jason Isbell

778        Complicated - Avril Lavigne

777        Where Are We Now? - David Bowie

776        I Believe in a Thing Called Love - The Darkness

775        How Deep is Your Love - Bee Gees

774        This Old Heart of Mine - Isley Brothers

773        A Spoonful of Sugar  (Mary Poppins)

772        To Ramona - Bob Dylan

771        All in Love is Fair - Stevie Wonder

770        Rapture - Blondie

769        Don't Speak - No Doubt

768        Alright - Supergrass

Don't think twice, it's ...

767        Can't Do Much - Waxahatchee

766        September Song - Ella Fitzgerald

765        Rolling in the Deep - Adele

764        Chop Suey! - System of a Down

763        Sound of the Underground - Girls Aloud

762        Losing My Religion - REM

761        Fuck da Police - NWA

760        The First Big Weekend - Arab Strap

759        Just Like Christmas - Low

758        Steppin’ Out - Joe Jackson

757        King of the Road - Roger Miller

756        Working Class Hero - John Lennon

755        Down In The Tube Station at Midnight - The Jam

754        For A Dancer - Jackson Browne

753        Burning Love - Elvis Presley

752        Ça Plane Pour Moi - Plastic Bertrand

This song is primarily not in English, so I am opening up myself to accusations of hypocrisy, but then again, he does song "I am the king of the divan" so it's probably just about ok.

751        It Ain't Necessarily So - Diahann Carroll

750        Rave On - Buddy Holly

No comments:

Post a Comment