Monday, 16 November 2026

Indie schmindie

Last week, the accursed Pitchfork published a list of the '100 Greatest Indie Rock Albums of All Time', which was abysmal. Abysmal to the point of utter meaninglessness.

It started with the impossible provocation that indie rock is "primarily an American musical art form" and then didn't even try to justify that patently arguable, pretty obviously false, assertion.

https://pitchfork.com/story/the-100-best-indie-rock-albums-of-all-time/

That would be enough in and of itself to discredit the list and needless to say, this brought out the wrath in other British music fans, but there were also the bizarre choices about what was and wasn't "indie". Not the Fall or My Bloody Valentine, apparently ... Sufjan Stevens but not Joanna Newsom ... Walkmen but not The Strokes...  etc etc... like, I'm sure you can justify these distinctions to yourselves, but, honestly, who cares?

Funnily enough, though, the list was accompanied by a questionnaire to various "indie" figures asking "What is indie rock?" and that was really interesting and showed up how silly the list was. So many different answers ...

The thing is, and perhaps this is a blessing of not having a great musical ear, genre just doesn't interest me. I'm pretty certain I've never made a list by genre. Considering, on pretty much every record, every artist worth their salt is trying to break outside a single genre, why are music journalists (particularly American ones) so obsessed with it?

I remember the school band that almost made it, Slushfund, described themselves as "post-grunge power indie-rock" and we all mocked them for how long-winded that was, but that's actually pretty succinct and simple if you consider how many genres great bands can incorporate.

What is indie to me? Indie is what I decided to be into when I was 16. Skinny kids with good haircuts. A sound not too clean. Guitars. Suede, Blur, even Oasis - Oasis are literally an indie band after all. The NME had its weekly indie chart and Oasis were always on it. Also on it were trip-hop, dance music, hip-hop, pop. Independent label music.

Does it need to be on an independent label? That side of things was certainly interesting to me in the 90s but there are so many (indie label/major distributor, major label/independent imprint) type things, that it is a little hard to make that distinction, and, in any case, that's really got nothing to do with what music sounds like.

Indie is, I guess, still most of what I'm into, without prejudice. Except, if someone asks me what I'm into, I'd be more likely to tortuously say... er ... guitar ... singer-songersongwriter ... alt ... country ... folk-influenced ... very eclectic actually ... all sorts ... more likely to say pretty much anything but indie. But it's probably mainly indie.

Indie is Belle and Sebastian and the Glasgow bands before them, it's thin, geeky, 80s music, it probably starts around Orange Juice, is C86, the Smiths, the Las, The Wonder Stuff. 

And, sure, yes, Pavement and Neutral Milk Hotel too.

It's basically any guitar music that isn't metal or soft rock, and some of them too, and there don't need to be guitars, and, yeah, i reckon if you asked people in Britain to name five indie bands they'd say Oasis, Arctic Monkeys, Radiohead, Blur and the Libertines, or something, and that's just fine. But not if they say Coldplay. I reckon that must be the line.

No comments:

Post a Comment